We had our second session of my new Freebooters campaign last night. Overall, we had a great time and everyone enjoyed it. We did have some PVP action (which I haven’t run a lot of in PbtA games), and I’m not sure I handled it the best way. The evil, greedy, but not very smart Elf Thief tried to pocket some treasure for herself right in front of the other characters. They protested, and a scuffle broke out in which the Halfling Cleric tried to swipe her off her feet with his staff. I had the cleric roll to hinder the thief, and then the thief roll a DEX save to avoid the sweep, which she made.
Any thoughts on how to better handle that kind of situation?