I really want to have a “GM talk” hangout at some points. It would basically just be about GM’ing Dungeon World, and maybe even the Apoc Engine in general.
It would be cool to collect a lot of questions from self-proclaimed n00bs that could be answered or discussed on air.
I think it could be pretty fun, and even helpful for some. Anyone who would want do participate in something like this?
raises hand by instinct
OK, first one to take the bait then 🙂
Always. I love to make myself more important then I am.
Well, you’re a pretty experienced GM, and I believe you could contribute a lot 🙂
That sounds like it’d be pretty cool. I’d be interested in getting involved, time permitting.
Great idea! Scheduling might be the only issue, but I’d love to participate!
I’m sure we can agree on some date and time.
This idea seems to have gotten a pretty warm reception 🙂
Again, time permitting, i would be very interested in participating in such a hangout.
And I have questions to contribute, there is a lot of stuff that comes up a lot.
Sounds like a cool idea. I just started running DW as my first world game so it would be great to get some ideas from more experienced GMs.
This sounds important, and would like a transcript, as I can rarely make the time for hangouts.
As a moderated hangout I guess?
I guess it should be moderated. I assume you mean there should be a chairperson?
Just to stop it to go into mumbling, ranting and to many anecdotes. Someone to keep us on track and give the questions to the panel.
Tim Franzke Good point. We should give it a week at least for gathering questions though…
Funny that you call it a panel 😉
Isn’t it basically? Or shouldn’t it be?
Maybe open up a google doc that people can write questions into and post it to the community?
I am interested in your ideas and would like to subscribe to your newsletter.
/sub
/sub
I’d like to help out, but, being the noob gm that I am, I could ask the questions and whatnot. Since you need someone to help in that area evidently. =P
Sounds like a plan
I’d be interested in attending, time differences permitting.
Count me in.
I doubt I’d be able to attend due to scheduling, but you guys should totally try and upload the result to youtube. I’d be interested in seeing what you all say.
/sub
Yeh i’m down for this.
In for questions
Question #1 here comes up a lot in my experience
http://www.reddit.com/r/DungeonWorld/comments/1ka72n/a_novice_question_about_dungeon_world/
I imagined it wouldn’t be very much about rules questions, more about GM’ing DW/AW in general, in contrast to more mainstream systems.
That said, this does seem to come up a lot. I think we should definitely have this one.
Tim Franzke Would you like to maintain a “questions” doc, or should I do it?
Since my computer will take a few more days to work you should I thin. I will add to it but can’t do more I fear.
General format idea:
There are big and small questions. Big are things like
How do you start up a first session
How to play DW outside the dungeon
If I want to create custom stuff, where/how do I start
And everyone on the panel adds their opinion to it. Then you have little/detail questions and just 1-2 people answer those. Maybe assign them beforehand so that people can prep a bit. Could also just be done rapid fire style.
Although thinks like first session, fronts etc are all big enough for a full panel I guess.
Tim Franzke Great idea here.
As for first sessions, I have run a lot of one-shots. I have some pretty solid advice here 🙂 At least it works pretty well for me 🙂
Google drive has some good spreadsheet/form compatability that can make it nice and easy to submit questions etc.
As a DM in general, who hasn’t yet run DW but wants to… I’m very much looking forward to this. Thanks Kasper Brohus Tim Franzke et al!
OK, we need to find a way to organize the question gathering and spread the word around.
How should we go about this.
We could make a post here. Then I could copy it all into a spread sheet on Google docs.
You could use a Google Docs Form (they’re easy to make) for submiting questions, and that would automatically post them to a spreadsheet.
EDIT: Or you could make a post here and people could plus one the questions they want to see answered the most. That way too you avoid duplicate questions being asked.
I forgot about Google forms. That would be a much better idea. Lol
Form -> Spreadsheet: Good idea!
A bit of extra work for the owner to group duplicates after the fact, but would make it very easy to enter them in a consistent way.
is anyone doing this?
I’m a work right now, but when I get home I can make a Google form and post it in the Tavern.
that would be nice of you Joshua Bailey i really have no experience with teh google form.
Four things I really want to discuss is
1) Fronts. Even Sage LaTorra admits these are tricky to rap your head around.
2) The shift in paradigm, the shift away from binary pass/fail resolution mechanics.
3) Combat. People have a really hard time wrapping their heads around this, as Tim Franzke said.
4) “How to prep for DW”, the draw maps, leave blanks principle.
I think these three points are incredibly important. They form the core for understanding how Dungeon World is different from many other mainstream RPG’s. At least, that’s how I see it. Each and every one of these has been discussed at some point.
at length! ^^
One thing that comes up every now and then is the question of situation modifiers, and why you should or shouldn’t use them. That might be worth discussing.
Joshua Bailey How do you propose the form should be presented? What questions should the form contain?
Sean Dunstan I totally agree! We should include that!
2 things also worth mentioning
When to roll/call for moves and whose responsibility this is.
and another thing, give me a second…
ah yeah, the “when something is not a player move, make a gm move instead”.
Basically “how to GM” is really important. So that everything you say is within in the principle, furthers the agenda and is a move.
soooo much stuff to talk about…
this GM flowchart shows what i am talking about
https://www.lucidchart.com/documents/view/4479-325c-520a025e-af7b-12420a008e8e/0
by Matteo Suppo
Yeah. It seems like it.
I’m making a move, I’m rolling the dice, just to see if I succeed at a price. Dungeon World is coming to toooown…
Seriously though, I’m making a “current agenda” doc, just to jot down the current awesome.
This is a rough draft of the topics so far
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1UETemfl2BMUCOLaIJqsQVIhkjaRra3a391CAwYXPJho/edit?usp=sharing
Anyone can comment 🙂
I figured it would really just be one empty field, and just say the type of questions that are being looked for. But… Hadn’t really thought it out much. I was planning on working it out when I got home. =P prolly try to open a chat hangout at least to talk about what’s being looked for here.
good idea but we maybe hit the hay by then ^^
Lol I should be home in 3 hours. Is that too late? (I don’t know what time zone you all are. =P I’m EST)
that is half past 12 ^^