Paladin Advance Move – Exterminatus
When you speak aloud your promise to defeat an enemy, you deal +2d4 damage against that enemy and -4 damage against anyone else. This effect lasts until the enemy is defeated. If you fail to defeat the enemy or give up the fight, you can admit your failure, but the effect continues until you find a way to redeem yourself.
If you were GM’ing what would you consider to be appropriate redemption, outside them going back and finishing the job?